School Board Conflicts and Civility: What Parents Should Know

School board elections—once quiet, local events about classroom priorities—are now becoming political battlegrounds across the country. The growing tension between ideological groups has spilled into education governance, raising concerns among parents and educators alike.

As seen in recent New Jersey school board elections, debates that once focused on textbooks, budgets, and student programs have increasingly turned into culture wars and political showdowns. Understanding this shift is essential for families who care about the stability and future of their children’s learning environment.

The Invasion of Politics into School Board Elections

Traditionally, school boards were designed as nonpartisan bodies focused on education policy—things like curriculum standards, staff hiring, and budgeting. According to the New Jersey School Boards Association (NJSBA), local boards make decisions that directly affect how students learn and how schools are funded.

However, over the past few years, school board elections nationwide have become more ideologically charged. Topics such as curriculum content, library books, and diversity programs have turned into political flashpoints. Interest groups and national organizations increasingly use local campaigns to advance broader social or political agendas.

An Education Week report highlights how the so-called “culture wars” are costing U.S. schools billions in resources, time, and staff burnout. As these conflicts intensify, local education governance risks becoming more about political influence than students’ best interests.

The Erosion of Political Civility

The shift toward polarization has brought with it a decline in political civility—the ability to disagree respectfully and collaborate productively.

In many districts, board meetings have grown heated, with personal attacks and misinformation replacing constructive dialogue. Some have even required police presence due to public hostility. The Pew Research Center found that a majority of Americans believe political discussion today is angrier, less respectful, and less fact-based than in the past.

This erosion of civility doesn’t just impact elections—it affects students, teachers, and communities. Children hear the tone adults set. When school discussions become divisive or disrespectful, it undermines the values of respect and cooperation that schools aim to teach.

Re-centering the Focus on Students

To move forward, school board elections and meetings must refocus on students, not politics.

Parents, candidates, and educators can all play a part in restoring balance and civility:

1. Keep Students at the Center
   Every decision—curriculum, policy, or budget—should be measured by one question: Does this benefit students’ learning and well-being?
2. Encourage Respectful Dialogue
   Civil disagreement is a cornerstone of democracy. Encouraging fact-based discussion rather than emotional confrontation models healthy civic behavior for children.
3. Promote Transparency and Participation
   When parents attend meetings, ask questions respectfully, and stay informed through trusted sources, they strengthen accountability and community trust.

Why Civility Matters for Children

A healthy school environment isn’t only shaped by teachers and curriculum—it’s also influenced by how adults conduct themselves in governance. Respectful, student-centered leadership fosters stability, teacher retention, and collaboration between schools and families.

As explained in Britannica’s entry on political behavior, civility enables rational decision-making and prevents governance from becoming gridlocked by emotion or ideology. For K-12 education, that principle is crucial: without civility, children’s needs get lost in the noise.

By restoring civility and collaboration, communities can ensure that school boards fulfill their true purpose—supporting academic growth, inclusivity, and opportunity for every student.

About Think Academy

Think Academy, part of TAL Education Group, helps K–12 students succeed in school today by building strong math foundations and critical thinking skills. At the same time, we focus on the bigger picture—developing learning ability, curiosity, and healthy study habits that inspire a lifelong love of learning. With expert teachers, proven methods, and innovative AI tools, we support every child’s journey from classroom confidence to long-term growth.

Want more insights on math learning and parenting? Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly tips and the latest resources.